Florida A&M denied FCS playoff berth ‘slap in the face of HBCUs,’ Willie Simmons says

Willie Simmons
Still disappointed a day after his team did not receive an at-large bid to the FCS playoffs, Florida A&M head coach Willie Simmons candidly stated that the Rattlers’ absence from the field was more than just the denial of one school.

“I think it is a slap in the face to all HBCUs,” Simmons said Monday during the SWAC coaches media call. “That we are a worthy team but the powers that be felt otherwise.”

The Rattlers had won nine straight games — eight of which were against FCS opponents — after starting the season 0-2 amid the turmoil surrounding its roster. However, that was not enough to get them into postseason play despite being ranked in the FCS coach poll.

“There are some teams that got in that we’re ranked higher than,” said Simmons. “There are teams that got in that we have more wins than. I think it is a slap in the face of us at the HBCU level. Hopefully, this resonates through our community that we speak up like we always have about injustices to our people.”

FAMU, and other schools on the bubble that did not make the 24-team field, pointed to the likes of several 7-4 teams — Montana, North Dakota, Idaho and Delaware  — that earned an at-large bid.

In the case of Montana, the Grizzlies lost three of its final four games, including a 34-point loss to in-state rival Montana State in the regular season finale.

Delaware dropped three of its last five still but found a way to get in while FAMU could not overcome, as suggested by FCS Selection Committee chairman Jermaine Truax, a 56-point loss to Jackson State in the Orange Blossom Classic and Division II Albany State on its schedule.

The immediate opinion after Truax’s evaluation what that Florida A&M needed to upgrade its non-conference schedule or examine playing the Orange Blossom Classic later in the year so as to not have an early season game carry that much conference implication.

While Simmons did indicate Florida A&M was considering other opponents besides Jackson State to feature in the matchup following the 2023 season, the problem — the coach suggested — was the playoff selection process.

‘I see a pattern’

“Do they (the FCS selection committee) feel it is okay to deny a 9-win team with eight FCS wins and loss to an undefeated top 5 team and another loss to a Power 5 team that will play for a conference championship?” Simmons asked. “If they feel that resume isn’t strong enough to get to the playoffs, then I think that’s a larger discussion. It’s not on us to change it. We’ve done what we needed to do. The problem is the way the committee vets teams.”

It was not lost on Simmons that he’s been in this frustrating position before. In 2015, then as Prarie View coach, the Panthers lobbied to be included in the FCS playoffs but did not make it despite going 8-2 overall and 8-1 in the SWAC that year.

Referring to himself as a “fact-finder” Simmons also pointed out other times HBCU programs were subbed from the FCS playoff field, including an 8-3 South Carolina State team in 2019.

“I see a pattern,” he said. “I’m just a fact-finder. I’m just a guy who points out facts. Those are the facts.”

Deion Sanders, who has not been a proponent of Jackson State being in the postseason because it is not financially advantageous, offered support for Simmons on Monday saying his colleague “was absolutely right” in the assessment of how the situation unfolded.

“He is 100 percent correct and I support him,” said Sanders.

The way too early HBCU Division I March Madness tournament projections

GSU Basketball
Last season, five HBCUs (two from SWAC, three from MEAC) advanced to the 2022 NCAA Division Ⅰ men’s basketball tournament. Also, three HBCUs (one from SWAC, two from MEAC) teams made it to the 2022 NCAA Division Ⅰ women’s basketball tournament.

On the men’s side, Alcorn State, Maryland Eastern Shore, and Morgan State lost in the First Four. Texas Southern won over Texas A&M-Corpus Christie in the First Four and later fell to the eventual champion Kansas Jayhawks in the round of 64. Norfolk State also lost to the defending champion at the time, the Baylor Bears, in the round of 64.

On the women’s side, Howard won a close one over Incarnate Word in the First Four before losing to the eventual champion South Carolina in the Round of 64. Also, in the First Four, Norfolk State narrowly lost to Drexel. 

Jackson State was the most impressive of all, pushing the veteran-laden LSU Tigers, coached by women’s hoops legend Kim Mulkey, all the way up until the very end before narrowly losing. Jackson State’s Ameshya Williams-Holliday became the first HBCU player drafted by the WNBA in 20 years.

In this article, I will try and predict which HBCU teams could make a run in March. 

Men’s tournament projections

Grambling State

The Grambling State Tigers will make it to their first NCAA Tournament in history thanks to being second in both offense and defense, scoring 82.5 points per game and allowing 65.5 points per game, allowing them a 17-point average margin of victory.

Carte’are Gordon is averaging 16 points per game and is second in SWAC in rebounding with 9.5 rebounds per game and is leading SWAC in blocked shots with two blocks per game. Shawndarius Cowart is averaging 16 points per game, leading SWAC in field-goal percentage at 58.8%, and is second in assists with 4.5 per game and second in steals with three per game.

Prairie View A&M

Just like the Tigers, the Prairie View A&M Panthers are both a tough offensive and defensive team, leading SWAC in scoring with 86.3 points per game and allowing the third-fewest points per game with 68.7 points per game.

It helps that they have SWAC’s second-leading scorer in Will Douglas, with 19 points per game, and is third in field-goal percentage (51.1). The Panthers also boast one of the top defensive players in Yahuza Rasas, who is sixth in rebounds with 6.3 per game and 11th in steals with 1.7 per game. Jeremiah Grambell is eighth in assists with three per game.

Norfolk State

The Norfolk State Spartans are fourth in offense with 77.2 points per game and third in defense by allowing 70 points per game. They lead in field-goal percentage at 48.2% and allow their opponents to shoot just 40.2%. 

Joe Bryant and Kris Bankston are top-10 in scoring in MEAC with 15.8 and 13.6 points per game, as well as being top-10 in field-goal percentage. The Spartans also have two of the top-five rebounders in MEAC, with Bankston averaging eight rebounds per game and Dana Tate averaging 6.3 rebounds per game. Bankston is also second in blocked shots, with 1.8 blocks per game. Christian Ings is sixth in assists with four per game and eight in steals with 1.8 per game. 

Morgan State

Another great two-way team is the Morgan State Bears, who are second in offense and defense, respectively, in the MEAC. They allow teams to shoot just 42.4% while shooting 38.8% from three-point range.

The Bears boast one of MEAC’s top defensive players in Malik Miller, the conference’s leading rebounder with 9.3 rebounds per game and also leads in steals with two per game. Another top defender is Khalil Turner, who is fourth in blocked shots with 1.3 blocks per game and fifth in steals with 2.3 per game. Miller is also third in assists with 4.8 per game. Collin Nnamene leads MEAC in blocked shots with two blocks per game.

Women’s tournament projections 

Arkansas-Pine Bluff

The thing that sets apart the Arkansas-Pine Bluff Golden Lions from the pack in SWAC is their defense, as they are allowing by far the fewest points in SWAC with 58.3 per game, the lowest field-goal percentage at 33.2% and the lowest 3-point percentage at 25.6%.

Maori Davenport leads the SWAC in rebounding, going away with 14 rebounds per game, and in shot blocking going away with 3.3 blocks per game. She is also the sixth-leading scorer with 13 points per game. Coriah Beck is another key player for the Golden Lions, as she is 10th in scoring with 11 points per game and leads SWAC in assists with 3.7 per game.

Prairie View A&M

The Prairie View A&M Panthers are both great offensively and defensively, leading SWAC in scoring by a large margin at 79.3 points per game and allowing just 66.5 points per game. 

Diana Rosenthal is SWAC’s leading scorer at 21.8 points per game, shooting 52.5% for the season. Destiny Jenkins is very important for this team, as she is scoring 10.5 points per game and leads SWAC in steals with four per game.

Norfolk State

Norfolk State is by far the MEAC’s best offensive team, averaging 83.3 points per game and allowing just 49.5 points per game. NSU is shooting 49.3% and allowing opponents to shoot just 28.3%.

The Spartans boast three of the top-10 scorers in MEAC with Deja Francis (15.8 points per game), Kierra Wheeler (11.5 points per game), and Camille Downs (10.8 points per game). Wheeler leads in rebounds with 11.5 per game, Francis leads in assists with 4.8 per game and Downs is second in steals with 3.3 per game.

Morgan State

The Morgan State Bears are second in scoring with 73.3 points per game and are first in scoring defense, allowing 46.3 points per game. They are also second in field-goal percentage at 40.7% and second in opposing field-goal percentage at 33.3%.

Two of the top-three MEAC scorers are on the Bears, as Ja’Niah Henson is averaging 16 points per game, and Charlene Shepherd is averaging 14.8 points per game. Three of the top-seven rebounders are also on the Bears, with Shepherd averaging 8.3 rebounds per game, Addison averaging 7.5 rebounds per game, and Sunshine McCrae averaging six rebounds per game.

South Carolina State linebacker BJ Davis enters transfer portal

BJDavis
South Carolina State linebacker BJ Davis has announced he is entering the transfer portal as a grad transfer with one year of eligibility remaining.

In 10 games during the 2022 season, Davis made a strong case for the MEAC Defensive Player of the Year award amassing 94 total tackles, eight tackles for loss, five interceptions, and seven pass breakups.

The Bulldogs senior was a pivotal member of the 2021 HBCU national championship team in which he was named to the All-MEAC first team.

In that season, Davis was among the MEAC leaders with 76 total tackles, including a Celebration Bowl performance that saw him record nine tackles and a fumble recovery.

South Carolina State is coming off a disappointing season in which they finished with a 3-8 overall record and went 1-4 against in the MEAC. This is the first time the Bulldogs have posted a conference record below .500 since 2017.

Florida A&M misses out on FCS postseason berth despite 9-win season

Florida Classic
Once again Florida A&M finished second in the SWAC East, but unlike last season the Rattlers will not be postseason bound.

The Rattlers (9-2, 7-1 SWAC) had won its last nine, including a 41-20 win against in-state rival Bethune-Cookman in the Florida Classic on Saturday to wrap up the regular season.

No HBCUs qualified for the postseason tournament after the playoff bracket was revealed Sunday afternoon on ESPNU.

The Rattlers — that entered Saturday ranked No. 24 in the FCS coaches poll — had hoped to make a final impression on the selection committee. But they likely did not earn a bid to the 24-team field because of its strength of schedule and lack of a quality win despite nine victories against Division I teams.

FAMU started the season 0-2 with losses to FBS North Carolina and a 59-3 loss to Jackson State in the Orange Blossom Classic before ending the year unbeaten.

The Tallahassee Democrat previously reported that the school is working with city officials and local business stakeholders to help secure a bid to host a playoff game at Bragg Memorial Stadium if the Rattlers were selected.

FCS Selection Committee chairman Jermaine Truax explained that FAMU — as one of the bubble teams — was weighed based on its overall body of work throughout the season and “opportunities to manage your schedule.”

That meant the committee took into account the Rattlers’ 56-point loss to Jackson State as well as its non-conference schedule that featured UNC and Division II Albany State.  The Rattlers had the 108th strength of schedule this season.

“Certainly, if your strength of schedule is not that strong against the other teams we are comparing you against you want to make sure you’re managing your schedule,” Truax said. “They (FAMU) certainly had an opportunity against Jackson State as a data point this year for the committee to look at and we did.”

Virginia Union suffers blowout loss against Wingate

VUU Football 2
The Virginia Union Panthers’ quest for a Division II championship has come to an end following a 32-7 home loss in the first round against Wingate.

The Panthers entered the DII playoffs as the No. 4 seed in Super Region II.

It was a struggle for Virginia Union’s offense against Wingate’s in the first half only managing 68 yards and committing two turnovers.

Meanwhile, Wingate’s defense was its best offense returning each of their first-half interceptions for a touchdown and getting out to a 21-0 lead.

After surrendering a safety and giving up a 49-yard touchdown pass, the Panthers trailed 29-0 with 7:17 left in the third quarter.

On the ensuing kickoff, Virginia Union got a huge boost with a 42-yard return by Larry Hackey. Quarterback Jakhari Grant capitalized off the return  and connected with John Jiles on a 48-yard touchdown pass to provide  the lone score of the game.

Grant ended the game with 164 yards  passing while Jiles had a game-high six receptions for 86 yards.

CIAA Offensive Player of the Year Jada Byers ended the game with 119 rushing yards on 21 attempts.

Virginia Union ended the season with a 9-2 overall record. Byers will now await word on whether he is a finalist for the Harlon Hill trophy.

Wingate will now advance to face No. 1 seed Benedict.

HBCU Sports Week 12 takeaways: Jackson State is still perfect and NC A&T wasn’t

6B6A6DE3 CB1B 4B99 ABF6 DA6462A59FE0
Although the HBCU football regular season has come to an end for most schools, the final full Saturday of games concluded with maximum excitement with several high-stakes games and dramatic finishes.

We saw a co-champion crowned in the MEAC, a SWAC team finishing the regular season undefeated for the first time in school history, and a team falling short of their first conference championship in a new conference.

Jackson State ends the regular season unbeaten

Travis Hunter, Jackson State
Photo: Justin Ford/HBCU Sports

For the first time in school history, the Jackson State Tigers end the regular season with a perfect 11-0 record after defeating Alcorn State 24-13.

The Tigers are one of three teams in all of the FCS to end the regular season unbeaten along with Sacramento State and Holy Cross.

This is the first time a Division I HBCU football team has finished a full 11-game regular season undefeated since North Carolina A&T in 2017.

Jackson State will now advance to the SWAC championship game looking to claim their second straight conference title against the yet-to-be-decided West division champion

NC A&T falls short of Big South title

The North Carolina A&T Aggies’ hopes for a Big South title were dashed on Saturday following a 38-17 loss to Gardner-Webb.

Photo: N.C. A&T Athletics

Entering this game, the Aggies were riding a seven-game win streak and were one win away in the season finale from claiming their first Big South title and an automatic bid in the FCS playoffs.

Despite the loss, Aggies running back Bhayshul Tuten added another 100-yard rushing performance, including a 61-yard TD run to his resume. He will now await word on whether he will receive the Big South Offensive Player of the Year award.

North Carolina Central holds off Tennessee Tech

The North Carolina Central Eagles ended the regular season on a strong note defeating Tennessee Tech by a narrow 22-20 margin.

Photo: North Carolina Central Athletics

Trailing 20-19, the Eagles secured the victory thanks to a game-winning 36-yard field goal by Adrian Olivo as time expired.

North Carolina Central concludes its regular season on a four-game win streak bringing its overall record to 9-2.

They will now advance to the Celebration Bowl and await the SWAC champion.

Howard wins a share of the MEAC title

Photo: Howard Athletics

For the first time since 1993, the Howard Bison claim a share of the MEAC championship following a decisive 35-6 win over the Morgan State Bears.

Saturday was Howard’s fifth straight win over Morgan State dating back to 2017. The Bison end the regular season with a 5-6 overall record and a 4-1 MEAC tally.

The Bison’s 4-1 record allows the program to claim a portion of the MEAC title with North Carolina Central. The Eagles, however, receive the Celebration Bowl berth as a result of their head-to-head win over the Bison.

Florida A&M wins Florida Classic

For the second straight year, the Florida A&M Rattlers come out of the Florida Classic victorious after defeating Bethune-Cookman Wildcats 41-20.

Florida A&M came into this game looking to build a case for an at-large bid in the FCS Playoffs. Earlier this week, it was reported that the Rattlers were putting together a bid to host a playoff game.

Photo: Florida A&M Athletics

While their selection into the FCS Playoffs is not guaranteed, this win was a step in the right direction. Florida A&M ends the regular season with a 9-2 overall record. It is their third straight season with at least 9 or more wins.

The FCS playoff field will be announced at 12:30 p.m. on ESPNU.

FAMU makes case for FCS playoff bid after dominant Florida Classic win

7D15D773 2A44 4940 8634 2E137CD0F36B Scaled 1
Five different players reached the end zone, led by two scores from Jaylen McCloud, as Florida A&M handily beat Bethune-Cookman 41-20 on Saturday afternoon inside Camping World Stadium.

The Rattlers improved to 9-2 on the year and 7-1 in Southwestern Athletic Conference play, while the BCU fell to 2-9 and 2-6.

Jeremy Moussa led Florida A&M’s passing attack with 195 yards through the air, tossing two touchdowns without throwing an interception.

Florida A&M got the better of Bethune Cookman at the Florida Classic. Justin Ford/HBCU Sports

McCloud led all FAMU rushers with 26 yards and two touchdowns in the contest. A.J. Davis also added 15 yards on the ground, averaging 5 yards per carry.

Moussa’s most prolific target in the ballgame was David Manigo, who caught five passes for 78 yards. Xavier Smith got in on the action in the passing game as well, hauling in five balls for 73 yards and one touchdown.

Anthony Dunn Jr led the Florida A&M defensive effort, recording six tackles, 4.0 TFL, three sacks, one forced fumble, and one recovered fumble. Isaiah Major added eight tackles, 3.0 TFL, and 2.5 sacks and Javan Morgan had five tackles, one interception, and two pass breakups in the win.

The Rattlers won the turnover battle in Saturday’s game, forcing two turnovers while avoiding any giveaways, with Florida A&M turning those takeaways into two touchdowns. Florida A&M converted on 44.4 percent of third-down attempts on the day. The Rattlers also went 1-for-1 on fourth down on a fake punt pass from Chris Faddoul to Jeremiah Pruitte.

Florida A&M’s defense held up against Bethune-Cookman’s offense, giving up 284 total yards. The Dark Cloud Defense took up residence in Bethune-Cookman’s backfield all game, piling up seven sacks and 14 total tackles for loss.

Florida A&M’s offense made the most of its trips to the red zone, scoring on four of its four trips, with all of those scores being touchdowns.

Florida A&M grabbed a 6-0 lead over Bethune-Cookman after scoring the game’s first points with 9:57 left in the first quarter. The Rattlers then followed with another score to increase the lead to 13-0.

Florida A&M continued to expand its advantage after Bethune-Cookman made it a 13-7 game, scoring again with 11:10 remaining in the second quarter to go up 20-7. The Rattlers continued to extend their lead, scoring again to go up 27-7.

Florida A&M continued to expand its lead after Bethune-Cookman made it a 27-20 game, scoring again with 10:11 left in the fourth quarter to make the score 34-20. The Rattlers kept scoring, tacking on a touchdown to increase their advantage to 41-20. Neither team scored again in the game.

Courtesy: Florida A&M Athletics 

Whew! The SWAC West got wilder after crazy Saturday. This is how it happened

PV SU1
Whew!

There are still some things that need to be settled in the SWAC West division.

Prairie View A&M had a chance to clinch the title with a win over the 1-9 Mississippi Valley State Delta Devils.

The Panthers lost 27-7.

As a result of Prairie View’s loss, Texas Southern then had temporary control of the West needing a win over Alabama A&M to secure the division.

Despite leading 20-3 with 13:29 remaining in the fourth quarter, the Tigers allowed 21 unanswered points culminated by a 38-yard touchdown run by Bulldogs quarterback Xavier Langford to fall 24-20.

Alcorn State had a chance to keep themselves alive in the SWAC West race despite longshot odds needing a win over Jackson State to do so. That plan fell through as the Braves lost 24-13.

Southern will have their chance to claim the division championship at the Bayou Classic against Grambling.

Should they lose, Prairie View A&M will win the division for a second straight season.

Howard clinches share of MEAC championship in win over Morgan State

Howard FB1

Howard saved its best game of the season for what was a historic day for the program.

Bison Quinton Williams threw two touchdown passes to lead an offense that racked up 369 total yards in a 35-6 win over Morgan State to claim a share of the MEAC championship.

Howard’s first-place finish is the first for the Bison since 1993 when the program won the Black college national title.

The Bison (5-6, 4-1) finished tied with North Carolina Central for first place but North Carolina Central won the head-to-head matchup with Howard and claimed the league’s automatic bid to the Celebration Bowl.

Alfonzo Graham — the MEAC’s leading rusher — had 111 yards rushing for the Bears (4-7, 2-3), but the Howard defense held Morgan State quarterbacks Roderick Walker and Duce Taylor to only 67 total yards passing.

Travis Hunter was the best player on the field against Alcorn State

TRAVIS HUNTER1
Jackson State doesn’t win the annual Soul Bowl without Travis Hunter.

The five-star true freshman didn’t stuff the stat sheet but an interception return for a touchdown and fourth-quarter TD reception was the difference in a Jackson State 24-13 win over Alcorn State Saturday.

A week after Hunter tallied his first interception and offensive touchdown versus Alabama A&M, the two-way player picked off Braves quarterback Tre Lawrence, avoided a would-be tackler, and raced 43 yards for the score.


Then later in the fourth quarter, with Jackson State holding on to a 17-14 lead, Hunter displayed his offensive prowess by hauling in a Shedeur Sanders pass between two defenders in the right corner of the end zone. After being called an incomplete pass by officials, a replay review overturned the initial ruling.

For the game, Hunter finished with two receptions for 49 yards and the lone TD. On defense, he broke up three passes in addition to the interception.

Jackson State completes the regular season 11-0 and will host the SWAC Championship Game in Jackson on Dec. 3 against the West division champion.