Despite 0-3 start, can these HBCU football teams compete in SWAC & MEAC?

Red And Orange Bold Fight Boxing Recap YouTube Thumbnail 10 1
Could the season already be over before conference play begins?

That’s the question Alcorn State, Bethune-Cookman, Morgan State, Mississippi Valley State, and Texas Southern might face after starting 0-3. While being winless is not a favorable outcome, there is still a lot of football left to play.

But do these teams have enough time — and talent — to make a run?

Inside the 0-3 start

Each team has faced a brutal opening schedule, and 0-3 marks reflect tough non-conference matchups against FBS or high-caliber FCS opponents more than a lack of postseason potential.

However, there are some positives within the group. Among them are:

  • Alcorn State features returning All-SWAC running back Jacorian Sewell and transfer quarterback Jaylon Tolbert, who previously played in the Celebration Bowl for Howard.

  • Bethune-Cookman understandably struggled against Florida International and Miami, but posted 503 yards of total offense in a 55-41 loss to MEAC champion South Carolina State a week ago. How the Wildcats can navigate what will be a difficult SWAC East slate could determine where B-CU has really improved.

  • Morgan State can always rely on its strong defensive core, but the team has frustratingly been unable to generate consistent offense over the last four years. Multiple 20-point performances versus Towson and South Alabama provide hope that production might jump once MEAC play begins.
  • Mississippi Valley State continues to rebuild, and first-year head coach Terrell Buckley described the work needed to transform the Delta Devils as “eye-opening.” Giving SWAC West favorite Southern a scare in the season opener could be (likely not, though) a prelude to MVSU’s potential to at least get out of the SWAC East basement. 

  • Texas Southern coach Cris Dishman isn’t happy with how the Tigers have played. After winning four games a year ago (something they hadn’t done in several years), the second-year coach senses the group has taken a step back—at least in non-conference play.

    Photo: Morgan State Athletics

Which 0-3 HBCU team can realistically make a run?

Alcorn State Braves possess the best odds to turn their season around and compete in the 2025 Celebration Bowl. Despite a winless start, their returning talent and the relative openness of the SWAC West give them a slight edge over the other teams that have yet to win a game.

  • The Braves were preseason picks to contend in SWAC West last year and retain much of that core, including Sewell, who is healthy and productive.

  • Tolbert’s experience as a prior Celebration Bowl participant brings a proven winner’s mentality, which is rare among HBCU QBs in this list.

  • Unlike Bethune or Morgan State, Alcorn’s schedule is more favorable relative to their talent and opponents.

Projected conference win-loss records

Team Conference Projected Conference Record
Alcorn State SWAC West 6-2 (best-case), 3-5 (worst-case)
Bethune-Cookman SWAC East 2-6 (realistic)
Morgan State MEAC 3-3 (best-case), 2-4 (likely)
Mississippi Valley St. SWAC East 1-7 (realistic)
Texas Southern SWAC West 2-6 (realistic)

HBCU football: Did Southern find something in its third string quarterback?

Red And Orange Bold Fight Boxing Recap YouTube Thumbnail 9
In what was classified as a business trip against an FBS opponent on the road, Southern might have discovered a valued asset.

Though the Jaguars were thoroughly outplayed in a 56-7 loss at Fresno State, one bright spot was the performance of backup quarterback Ashton Strother.

Southern University head football coach Terrence Graves praised Strother, a transfer from Coahoma Community College, who joined the team late in fall camp but quickly proved himself as a competitor.

“Well, I tell you what, Ashton’s a pleasant addition,” Graves said. “We lost a quarterback right before camp for some personal reasons, and we were down. Because of relationships our coaches have with others, we were able to bring him in. He came in late, but he came in with the right attitude.”

Strother, a junior, completed 9 of 14 passes for 127 yards on Saturday against the Bulldogs. His first drive resulted in a 1-yard rushing touchdown as he led a nine-play drive for 75 yards.

Cam’Ron McCoy, a Jackson State transfer, played briefly and went 1 for 4 with four passing yards against Fresno State.

Jalen Woods, the starter coming into the regular season, did not play due to a concussion.

Graves noted Strother’s energy and willingness to learn stood out from the start.

“He wants to learn, he’s a competitor, and he does the little things that you want to see as a coach,” Graves said. “And we put him in the game on Saturday, and it was like, ‘Hey, I’ve got my shot. Let me go and try to lead this team to victory.’”

Strother, who had only weeks to grasp Southern’s offense, showed poise in his first real action.

“It feels good, you know, got kind of those first-game jitters out of the way,” Strother told The Advocate after the game. “But now, we got to get back to Baton Rouge and protect home.”

 

These were the most attended games in week 3 of the HBCU football season

Jackson State University
Alcorn State’s trip to SEC country tops this list of the 10 most attended games from week three of the HBCU football season.

Alcorn State vs. Mississippi State: 49,158

Norfolk State vs. Rutgers: 41,011

Southern vs. Fresno State: 37,210

Morgan State vs. Toledo: 22,846

Prairie View A&M vs. Rice: 22,260

Jackson State vs. Tuskegee: 18,642

Alabama State vs. Miles: 18,101

Howard vs. Morehouse: 16,248

North Carolina A&T vs. Hampton: 15,806

Florida A&M vs. Albany State: 14,370

HBCU professor suspended for social media post criticizing Charlie Kirk

Southern 1
A Southern University law professor was suspended over social media comments following the death of conservative provocateur and activist Charlie Kirk.

Kirk was fatally shot while speaking at an event at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10. The suspect, 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, was arrested two days later.

Kirk, a co-founder of Turning Point USA and a prominent conservative figure, was widely mourned across right-wing circles, while his death has sparked heated political debate nationwide.

In Kelly Carmena’s post obtained by WAFB-TV in Baton Rouge, she wrote, “I will 1000% wish death on people like him. He is the epitome of evil, and I have no compassion, not even a minute ounce of it for people like him who go around spewing hate the way he does.”

Southern University Board Chairman Tony Clayton stated, “She has been suspended effective immediately based on the cause that she participated in conduct that was prejudicial to the university.” He added, “Distasteful statements should not be tolerated particularly as it relates to death. That is tantamount to participating and inciting violence and spewing hate. That conduct will not be tolerated at Southern University period.”

The fallout following Kirk’s death has extended beyond Southern University. Across the country, employees in various sectors have faced eprimands, suspensions, or firings over critical or celebratory comments about Kirk on social media.

U.S. Vice President JD Vance urged accountability for those expressing sentiments that glorify or dismiss Kirk’s killing, underscoring a broader crackdown on speech deemed hateful or inflammatory in the aftermath of the shooting.

Southern University continues its formal investigation as it moves toward terminating Carmena’s employment, the TV station reported.

Cris Dishman tries ‘not to be rude’ in response to SWAC media call question

Cris Dishman

Texas Southern dropped to 0-3 on Saturday after a 31-7 loss, which second-year head coach Cris Dishman called disgusting and an effort he didn’t sign up for in postgame comments.

On Monday, reporter Perry Daniels asked Dishman during the SWAC coaches’ media call to provide more details about job expectations.

Daniels: “Help me comprehend the statement, ‘This isn’t what you signed up for.’ I don’t quite grasp the meaning of that.”

Dishman: “Well, Mr. Daniels, let me take it very slow. When coaches sign up to take a job, I didn’t sign up where our guys, our coaches, or even me, decide not to go out there and play good football. That’s what I was talking about. I wasn’t talking about anyone else but myself.” Now you got it, right?”

Dishman was pressed further by the reporter and responded with candor.

“Let me say this again, and I’m trying not to be rude,” Dishman responded. “My job title is head coach. I have to get our players to play each and every day, get them to study hall, get them to graduate. My main focus this year is to get 1000 APR points. My main focus this year is to win the (SWAC) West and win the SWAC. Those are our team goals, and our captains and seniors on our team have signed off on them. That’s what we’re fighting to do. Our preseason is over, and it’s time to get down to business.”

Here is the exchange in full:

Texas Southern will be on a bye this week before playing at Mississippi Valley State on Sept. 27.

Hoffman’s HBCU football observations: Edward Waters is dangerous

Red And Orange Bold Fight Boxing Recap YouTube Thumbnail 8
Week three of the HBCU football season provided its fair share of intrigue with some fascinating endings that has everyone.

One game in particular has fans crying foul feeling like an underdog got the short end of the stick in an emotional ending.

Elsewhere, an SIAC team has put its peers on notice with a significant win over a CIAA contender, a three-year losing streak was put to rest, a pair of teams fought through adversity to survive upset bids.

Here are the five takeaways from week three of the HBCU football season.

1. Grambling State-Kentucky State’s controversial ending

Grambling State got more than it bargained for when it welcomed Kentucky State into Eddie Robinson Memorial Stadium for its home opener.

The Tigers were taken to the brink, needing a touchdown in the waining moments of regulation to send the game to an extra period.

Beginning overtime on defense, Grambling State put Kentucky State away, forcing a fumble and returning it for a touchdown in a play that has been the subject of scrutiny.

Facing third-and-four, Kentucky State quarterback Torrence Bardell threw a short pass to Jon McCall, but ran into a crowd and was seemingly stopped short of a first down.

However, instead of the referees ruling that McCall was down by forward progress, they allowed the play to develop, resulting in the Tigers forcing the turnover and returning it for the game-winning score.

2. Edward Waters’ hot start

Edward Waters put the world on notice that they are a legit SIAC contender, keeping its record unblemished with a 41-38 win over the two-time reigning CIAA champion Virginia Union.

This is Edward Waters’ first 3-0 start as a member of the SIAC and its first 3-0 start in general in 60 years.

In addition, they have scored over 40 points in all three of their contests this season, ranking sixth in the country in scoring offense.

Before Saturday, Virginia Union had not lost against a non-conference Division II opponent since 2021. Also, Edward Waters held a 2-5 record against non-conference opponents, including three straight losses against Florida Memorial.

The Tigers will have a tough test on its hands in their next contest when they go on the road to Daytona Beach to face Bethune-Cookman.

3. North Carolina A&T’s FCS losing streak ends

After three years of being a member of the Coastal Athletic Association (CAA), North Carolina A&T has finally won a conference game, beating Hampton 33-30.

The Aggies had been 0-16 in conference competition and had lost its last 17 games against FCS opponents prior to their win over Hampton on Saturday.

This was also their first home victory against an FCS opponent since 2022, having lost their last nine such games.

Through the first three games under head coach Shawn Gibbs, the Aggies have shown signs of trending in the right direction toward becoming a championship contender once again.

4. Florida A&M can Bragg again

Florida A&M averted disaster in its home opener against Albany State, overcoming an early 14-3 deficit to claim its first win of the season.

Needing a spark to start the second half, the Rattlers scored two touchdowns in the first three minutes to shift the momentum completely in their favor.

The Rattlers showed resilience against a credible team that had been averaging 50 points per game through their first two games.

Heading into their bye week with a win will do wonders for their confidence when they return to open conference play against Alabama State.

5. Johnson C. Smith survives an Elizabeth City Scare

Johnson C. Smith survived a scare of its own this weekend, fending off an upset-minded Elizabeth City State on the road for a 21-17 win.

Despite Johnson C. Smith finding a way to come away with a win, scoring on a go-ahead 62-yard touchdown pass in the final four minutes, Elizabeth City State gave the Golden Bulls its first big test of the year.

The Vikings held the Golden Bulls to 140 total yards over the previous seven drives before they scored the eventual game-winning touchdown.

This included forcing three three-and-outs and the Golden Bulls’ only turnover on an interception at the end of the first half.

With the stakes on the rise for Johnson C. Smith, ahead of its next contest against reigning CIAA champion Virginia Union, having shown the fortitude to battle back from a deficit could prove to be valuable entering a game with postseason implications.

Mickey Joseph says there’s a rules lesson to be learned in Grambling OT win

Screenshot 2025 09 15 143303
Grambling State coach Mickey Joseph praised his team for not allowing game officials to determine the outcome of its thrilling overtime win over Kentucky State.

Even if the Tigers’ 37-31 win needed a replay review to decide it.

On the third play of OT, Kentucky State quarterback Torrance Bardell completed a pass over the middle, but Grambling defensive back Tyrell Raby stripped Jon McCall and ran 83 yards for the winning TD.

Game officials went to a replay review to investigate whether McCall’s forward progress had been stopped before he lost the football in a scrum of bodies.

Joseph explained Monday during the SWAC football coaches media call that his players are coached to keep competing until officials officially stop the play.

Game officials did not blow the play dead, and the action continued until Raby scored.

“I haven’t heard a whistle in a college game in the last seven years about stopping plays,” Joseph said. “So we teach our kids to play until they say stop.”

He emphasized that offensive players often prolong drives by pushing forward after the initial contact, so defenders must stay alert and continue fighting for the ball.

Joseph singled out Raby for his hustle, saying, “It was a great job by him just to keep playing. We played to the echo of the whistle. We didn’t hear a whistle, so you know it had to be a fumble.”

The Grambling coach also noted the fine line officials face when deciding when to blow the whistle, balancing player safety with allowing honest competition. “If you’re going to protect the kids, you’ve got to blow a whistle and stop it, but you also have to stop when linemen come in and blow into the pile to try to push somebody forward,” Joseph said.

Ultimately, the call stood, and the turnover proved to be a key moment that helped Grambling State seize control of the contest. Joseph made clear that his team will continue embracing an impactful but straightforward rule: compete hard until the whistle sounds.

HBCU Sports reached out to Kentucky State head coach Felton Huggins for his perspective on the play, but a school representative indicated he would not comment on the play.

What Michael Vick said about Virginia Tech coaching job conversation

Michael Vick
As a report surfaced about Michael Vick possibly being a name to watch in the Virginia Tech football coaching search, the Hokies’ most famed football alum says his focus is solely on his current job.

“My primary focus, until the end of time, is what we do here at Norfolk State,” Vick said during Monday’s MEAC Coaches’ Conference. “That’s all we can focus on right now. I hope our guys aren’t looking at any newspaper clippings or what’s happening on social media, because I don’t do it.”

Virginia Tech fired Brent Pry following a 45-26 loss at home to Old Dominion, which dropped the Hokies to 0-3 on the season.

FOX Sports sideline reporter and The Athletic College correspondent Bruce Feldman published a piece suggesting Virginia Tech could be interested in Vick as Pry’s replacement.

Vick, however, says his focus is on the Spartans’ game this week, a visit from FCS independent Sacred Heart.

“My job is to lead this team and have them follow my lead,” he said. “We’re already looking at game film, breaking things down and getting ready for this week’s game.”

Ohio State alum calls out school for ‘shameful’ way it treated HBCU band

Red And Orange Bold Fight Boxing Recap YouTube Thumbnail 5

A longtime Ohio State University alum and passionate Buckeyes football fan is sticking up for the Grambling State marching band.

In an opinion piece submitted to the Columbus Dispatch, author Penny Miller expressed her “deep disappointment” over how the World Famed Tiger Marching Band was treated during the school’s visit to Ohio Stadium last Saturday.

Miller, who described herself as the mother of a former band member, didn’t mince words about how Ohio State was unfair.

“Every time it was their (Grambling’s) turn to play spirit music during the game, instead of spectators being able to appreciate their contribution to the day, excessively loud music was blasted over the sound system, drowning out the music that the Grambling band was making,” she wrote in a message addressed to Ohio State’s president, athletic director and band director.

She said fans in attendance “did not get to experience the back and forth between the Grambling band and the Ohio State band,” calling the decision to play “loud, awful music when it was Grambling’s turn to play throughout the entire game” unacceptable.

Highlighting the dedication of both bands, she said, “Those who participate as members of both bands put in lots of time, hard work and effort to be outstanding musicians. You are great on your merit and deserve to be appropriately heard.”

In closing, Miller called for respect and hospitality, stating, “Ohio State University was shameful in the way we treated the Grambling band.”

Her comments serve as a reminder that HBCUs—whether they have a football team or marching bands—must deal with challenges at PWIs.

The college football media is trying to fuel Michael Vick back to Virginia Tech

Red And Orange Bold Fight Boxing Recap YouTube Thumbnail 6
Michael Vick has only been a college football head coach for 15 minutes, but he’s already being suggested as the next coach at a non-HBCU school.

Bruce Feldman, the National College Football Insider for The Athletic and a sideline reporter for FOX College Football, dropped an article on Sunday that provided possible targets for the next Virginia Tech coach after the school fired Brent Pry.

Here is what Feldman, who ironically enough broke the news that then-Jackson State coach Deion Sanders had mutual interest in the Colorado job (before he eventually took it following the 2022 season), wrote about Vick and Virginia Tech.

The wild-card candidate is probably the greatest player in Hokies history: Michael Vick, who carried them to the 2000 BCS title game.

The Hampton Roads product from Newport News, Va., jumped into the college coaching ranks last winter, taking the job at FCS Norfolk State. He’s 1-2 and learning on the job. It’s too soon to tell much from how things are going to go for him as a college coach, though he would be able to recruit very well in his home state. But getting a more experienced, proven head coach might seem like a safer option after Pry, a first-time head coach, failed to gain any traction building up this program.

Feldman listed names like South Carolina coach Shane Beamer, Ohio State wide receivers coach Brian Hartline, and former Hampton assistant and current Southern Miss. coach Charles Huff who would make solid candidates for the job, too.

Feldman wasn’t the only college football reporter to connect Vick with Virginia Tech. On3 Sports writer Pete Nakos also mentioned (behind a paywall) the Norfolk State coach as someone the school should consider.

What does this all mean? Could Vick be a serious candidate?

Vick has gone on record to proclaim that he did want to be a Power Four coach at some point, saying, “I see myself potentially going to a Power Five one day. That’s the goal. Anything I get myself involved in, I’m always going to look into the future and where I can take it or where I can go.”

Photo: Norfolk State Football/X

But he remains committed to building the Norfolk State football program and coaching chops.

After all, Vick is just three games into his tenure and has yet to prove anything at the collegiate level. While some alums and boosters might be led by nostalgia for wanting Vick, Virginia Tech desperately wants to win now with a proven winner.

He’s not Sanders, who quickly turned Jackson State into an HBCU juggernaut, or Eddie George, who led Tennessee State to a conference championship before bolting for Bowling Green after four seasons.

Trusting a green coach — no matter his celebrity status or ties to the school likely won’t be the play.