Courtesy/Mississippi Valley State Athletics

Mississippi Valley State softball players are speaking out about allegations of coaches engaging in a consistent culture of verbal abuse with players.

Former MVSU catcher Lacy Wilburn, who quit the team following her junior season, told HBCU Sports on Friday that her “main concern is the emotional and verbal treatment that current players are getting.”

Wilburn, who last played in 2019, detailed a pattern of behavior by assistant coach Brittany Tillery and head coach Lee Smith that left some players depressed and one publicly admitting contemplating suicide.

“She (Tillery) is not anything a coach should be,” said Wilburn. … “The things she says to you because she’s attacking you as a person, stick with you for years.”

Wilburn cited multiple examples of abuse.

She said Tillery would often chide her about her physique as a weight loss motivation tool.

But the comments, she explained, were more demeaning than nurturing.

“It was, ‘You don’t look good in your uniform. ‘Don’t you want to look better?’ Your build is bad,'” said Wilburn, who told a Jackson, Mississippi television reporter that she developed depression and turned to alcohol to cope. “It was never about the sport.”

Allyssa Montes, who also was part of the Devilettes from 2017 to 2019, crafted a lengthy social media post writing that coaches “broke me mentally and ran my body to the ground” during her collegiate career at MVSU.

Also read: Howard football coach Ron Prince resigns amid abuse, intimidation allegations

“It was almost as if coaches wanted to constantly embarrass me in front of my teammates, calling me out about my personal life,” Montes wrote. … “I had suicidal thoughts and I’ll never get over the fact that they caused all this distress.”

Montes also claimed that she was forced to play despite being ill, was told by Tillery that she was “too mentally unstable” to live on her own after attempting to secure off-campus housing and alleged coaches excessively ran players to exhaustion as punishment.

Montes, who was the team’s ace pitcher during her time, said the harsh treatment she received from Lee, in particular, was unexpected because she never complained or was disrespectful toward the coaching staff.

“I told my roommate to tell my parents that if I killed myself it would because of Coach Lee,” she told HBCU Sports. “I had it the worst.”

During the period in which the alleged verbal abuse took place, several players, including Wilburn, contacted the university’s president.

Players were told in response that an investigation would be made into the allegations.

An athletic department spokesperson has yet to respond to a request for comment from HBCU Sports.

The aggrieved athletes say they’re coming forward, not out of spite, but because they do not want other athletes to be treated similarly.

“I hope people are stronger than I was at that time to be able to stand up for myself,” said Wilburn, who wants Tillery and Smith removed from the program. “It’s not just Valley softball. There are a ton of other athletes at Valley saying the same thing about their sport, too.”


  1. Kendrick we are experiencing the same kind of abuse at Cedar Falls High School. The AD has been notified but yet the coach still remains in place. This type of abuse needs to stop. Thanks for bringing this out in the open.

  2. Reading this article is completely appalling. I ve know Coach Smith for more than 20 years. I ve also attended many of his softball practices, and games, as well as observe his duties, and activities, including intramural events around Valley campus for years. No one time have I ever seen, nor heard anything negative about Coach Smith. I know for a fact that, because of Valley budget woes, Coach Smith has taken his own funds to buy softball equipment, support the recruiting process, and to try to maintain a stable program. No !! I dont know the true motivation for these complaints, and I wouldn’t dare draw a conclusion about this situation that I dont know nothing about. However, one thing that I can speak to with 100% certainly, and that is that Coach Smith is an gentle giant, and he is a man of impeccable character, and a man of championship qualities, of which throughout his career at Valley, has always been displayed !! I pray for the peace of these former students athletes, and I certainly pray for the day that all who know Coach Smith will stand up and let the world know that what’s been accused is not indicative of the Coach that WE KNOW !! BLESSINGS !!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here