Since full-fledged desegregation that resulted in the influx of black amateur athletes suiting up for predominately white colleges and universities began nearly a half-century ago, HBCUs have struggled to keep in the talent acquisition arms race.

The decline in blue chip athletes has left black colleges behind in generating revenue, landing lucrative TV contracts and winning national championships.

But one person — a brave, forward-thinking soul — believes that HBCUs can be competitive by doing what no other group of universities legally can do.

Paying the athletes.

Longtime critic of the NCAA and San Francisco-based economist Andy Schwarz suggests that an HBCU-exclusive basketball league can be formed with the idea of compensating the America’s best young basketball players.

Here is how the business model would work, Schwarz told VICE Sports.

The way Schwarz and his HBCU league co-founders—Ohio–based sports and entertainment attorney Richard Volante and Washington, D.C.–based author and historian Bijan Bayne—see it, the NCAA is a bit like a traditional taxi company, while their concept is akin to Uber or Lyft. The league would consist of at least 16 members drawn from the four current NCAA Division I and II HBCU conferences, institutions such as Howard University and Florida A&M; its athletes would be full-time students.

They also would be paid to play basketball, between $50,000 and $100,000 a year. Moreover, they would be allowed to endorse products, sell autographs, sign with agents, accept gifts from boosters, declare for the NBA draft, and even be drafted by NBA teams without losing their eligibility.

Schwarz says the proposed league also would dovetail with the HBCU mission to serve and support the African-American community. Currently, amateurism in major college sports functions as a de facto racial wealth transfer, redistributing what I estimate to be $2.2 billion annually from black football and men’s basketball players to predominantly white administrators, coaches, and non-revenue sport athletes. Permitting athlete pay would begin to balance the ledger.

“And if this league takes off, this is an opportunity for people to be general managers, to work at all different levels of a sports enterprise,” Schwarz told VICE. “So it’s not just black coaches being involved, it’s a lot of staffing in a league that’s based within the HBCU community and doesn’t have the impediments we sometimes see to African-Americans getting those jobs.”

This might be just crazy enough to work for HBCUs that have been searching for so long to replicate it’s past glory and influence in college sports.


  1. Wait, the NCAA would put the burden of paying student-athletes on the HBCUs, but the Clemsons and Notre Dames of the world are above paying student-athletes? Very hypocritical of the NCAA and those Power 5 universities. Also, could the HBCUs bear that financial burden? The NCAA is trying to eliminate HBCUs.

    • They already have top notch facilities, REFUNDS, and being their is a luxury within itself. 24 hour cafes, multiple cafes… You wouldn’t understand the struggle until you have attended an HBCU with little to no budget.

  2. This is brilliant. I think HBCU leadership would be a fool to let this opportunity go by. I think people need to get the word out and demand action by HBCU leadership. Time for black men to benefit black institutions and their families.

    • Unfortunately, the white folks trying to put this together have access to capital that ultimately lead to exploration of black athletes…AGAIN! While I agree that players needs options to expose their talent, don’t fall the promise of $50-$100K while playing as an amateur. You will hurt your brand, and be ineligible to play in the NCAA tournament. If money is what you want or need, go pro!

  3. I’ve thought of this very concept recently. The top 50 2018 Basketball Recruits are all African American… Imagine if they all choose HBCU Conference’s. If this could happen for say 4 years straight the balance of power would shift to HBCU’s.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here