SWAC FB Coaches 2023 Ranked 1-12


PBSwag77 said:
Let the debate begin 😂 My list is based off overall record, # of SWAC titles, head-to-head, experience, etc. (don’t kill me just my opinion so let’s have a fun debate):

  1. Fred McNair (41-29) 2 SWAC titles
  2. Willie Simmons (33-12)
  3. Connell Maynor (94-51) 1 SWAC
  4. Eric Dooley (26-21)
  5. Hue Jackson (11-44)*NFL (3-8)*NCAA
  6. Eddie Robinson (6-5)
  7. Bubba McDowell (6-5)
  8. Clarence McKinney (9-27)
  9. Ed Reed (1st yr)
  10. TC Taylor (1st yr)
  11. Alonzo Hampton (1st yr)
  12. Kendrick Wade (1st yr)
Click to expand...

I am not sure it’s fair to rank any coach that hasn’t coached a down yet. Other than that, I don’t have a problem with the list. I suspect Dooley will be moving up the list though within the next year or two…..We’re certainly not keeping a coach that is worse than AAMU coach…..LOL. Having a coach that is not SUperior to Alcorn will get you sent to Norfolk State and FAMU is a problem as well but I digress….LOL
 



These are facts...

How do you rank a head coach as 6th best in the SWAC who was/did:

1. Given the keys to a team that returned 18 of 21 starters
2. Allow 2 KEY defensive stalwarts to depart
3. Didn't have the common sense to bring in a heralded JUCO QB who is a true dual-threat vs house pretenders on the roster who are mere RBs playing the QB position (except the one all-state true freshman)
4. Won games conference games STRICTLY on the will of student-athletes vs inept scheming/lack of coaching and those wins basically had a wrap for a divisional crown in hand
5. This is the biggie... allowed his team to simply piss away the divisional crown and could not beat Alcorn St, MVSU, & SU although EACH of those programs had specific weaknesses/issues occurring about their program. PV made SU's McCray look like Johnny Unitas w/ the lackluster defensive effort. Thank God McDaniel didn't play the game from start to finish or SU would've rung up 100+ points lol
6. Allowed fcs startup program 6/7 y/o iwu to come into your house and DOMINATE you
7. Allowed fcs startup program 3 y/o acu to beat you like a red-headed stepchild
8. Allowed your 2 best YOUNG RBs to hit the transfer portal immediately after the season

TOP 6? I seriously think not. 👎🏿 Fax...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top