HBCU football picks: Could a top team Black College Football be on upset alert?

Nsu Football
HBCU Football 2024 has proven to be a rollercoaster of emotions for teams, coaches, fans…and prognosticators such as myself.

Week 4 was the worst week I’ve had since starting these picks for HBCU Sports last season, but the beauty of all the upsets and surprises is that they give us all something to talk about…and think about as I share Week 5’s predictions.

Before we can do that, let’s take a quick look back at the week that wasn’t.

Last Week’s Record: 19-12
2024 Overall Record: 76-37-1
Best Pick: North Carolina Central 21, North Carolina A&T 17 (Central won 66-24)
Worst Pick: Take your pick! We’ll go VMI 27, Norfolk State 13 (Norfolk State won 32-10)

Game Of the Week: Grambling State (3-1, 0-0 SWAC West) vs. Prairie View A&M (1-3, 0-2 SWAC West, State Fair Classic at the Cotton Bowl in Dallas, Texas, Saturday, Sept. 28, 7 p.m. EST, ESPN+

Grambling’s best start in seven seasons has come in a non-conference setting (last week’s win against Jackson State didn’t count towards the standings), so they’ll make their SWAC West debut this season against the defending division champion Panthers, who are desperate to avoid a knockout blow.

The Tigers’ defense, which has forced 15 turnovers in the season’s first four games, will look to stifle PVAMU’s offense while Myles Crawley looks to guide the GSU offense to enough points for the victory. Prairie View needs to start fast, or else they’ll be on the outside looking in at this year’s Wild Wild West race.

Prediction: Grambling State 27, Prairie View A&M 17

North Carolina Central (2-2, 0-0 MEAC) vs. Norfolk State (2-3, 0-0 MEAC) at the Circle City Classic, Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, Indiana, Saturday, Sept. 28, 3 p.m. EST, ESPN+

The MEAC conference schedule starts at a neutral site, with NCCU and Norfolk State coming off huge wins against in-state opponents. Trei Oliver’s walking wounded are healing up at just the right time, as their 66-24 punishment of rival North Carolina A&T suggests, while Norfolk State is looking to throw a wrench into the Eagles’ Celebration Bowl plans.

This will come down to a battle of two new starting quarterbacks—Central’s Walker Harris and the Spartans’ Jalen Daniels. Harris has had some ups and downs in taking over for Davius Richard, while Daniels is a sophomore seeing his first Division I college action. Last week against VMI (20-29, 277 yards and three touchdowns) was a glimpse into a bright future for him.

Whichever quarterback can get their team up and down the field and consistently scores points will win the game, which, of course, is the name of the game.

Prediction: North Carolina Central 34, Norfolk State 31

Clark Atlanta (3-0-1, 2-0 SIAC) at Lane (1-2, 1-1 SIAC), Saturday, Sept. 28, 3 p.m. EST, ESPN+

The Panthers’ stunning comeback win over Division I Bethune-Cookman last week gave the program their best start since 1974, and they’ll look to continue that momentum against a vastly improved Lane team. The Dragons have looked competitive outside of the Jackson State game and will look to not only end Clark Atlanta’s unbeaten dreams but announce themselves as a SIAC contender as well.

Prediction: Clark Atlanta 38, Lane 36

Fayetteville State (2-1, 1-0 CIAA) at Virginia State (1-2, 0-0 CIAA), Saturday, Sept. 28, 2 p.m. EST, CIAASN

A humbling loss at home to Winston-Salem State has the Trojans searching for answers, and those answers may not come as a determined Fayetteville State team looks to start their drive to another CIAA championship game appearance. This looks to be another defensive struggle, with neither team’s offense setting the world on fire. VSU needs a strong offensive performance, or the Broncos could walk away with a key win and put the Trojans behind the 8-ball.

Prediction: Virginia State 20, Fayetteville State 17

Division I

Campbell 28, Delaware State 20
Princeton 25, Howard 19
Stony Brook 21, Morgan State 14
South Carolina State 30, North Carolina A&T 21
Tennessee State 22, Charleston Southern 17
William & Mary 35, Hampton 24
Alabama State 18, Bethune-Cookman 13
Jackson State 28, Texas Southern 17
Alcorn State 13, Mississippi Valley State 12

Division II/NAIA

Virginia Union 33, Shaw 29
Livingstone 26, Lincoln (Pa.) 14
Bowie State 20, Winston-Salem State 18
Johnson C. Smith 31, Bluefield State 13
Miles 28, Allen 22
Benedict 27, Morehouse 24
Albany State 32, Kentucky State 19
Fort Valley State 30, Savannah State 20

Tuskegee 28, Edward Waters 24

West Virginia State 34, West Virginia Wesleyan 14
Southwest Baptist 23, Lincoln (Mo.) 13
Butler 37, VUL 10
Texas College 27, Langston 21

HBCU Football Scoreboard – (Week 5)

GSU Vs PV1
Here are the results of every HBCU football game in week 5.

Division I

Delaware State 41 vs. Campbell 44

Norfolk State 10 vs. North Carolina Central 37

Howard 13 vs. Princeton 30

Alabama State 26 vs. Bethune-Cookman 21

Morgan State 3 vs. Stony Brook 22

Tennessee State 13 vs. Charleston Southern 9

Hampton 7 vs. William & Mary 49

North Carolina A&T 25 vs. South Carolina State 45

Alcorn State 42 vs. Mississippi Valley State 21

Prairie View A&M 36 vs. Grambling State 34

Jackson State 43 vs. Texas Southern 14

Division II

Shaw 7 vs. Virginia Union 42

Livingstone 15 vs. Lincoln (PA) 14

Bowie State 14 vs. Winston-Salem State 28

Miles 33 vs. Allen 13

Benedict 21 vs. Morehouse 5

West Virginia State 48 vs. West Virginia Wesleyan 22

Lincoln (Mo.) 13 vs. Southwest Baptist 17

Fayetteville State 18 vs. Virginia State 35

Clark Atlanta 38 vs. Lane 28

Kentucky State 21 vs. Albany State 49

Johnson C. Smith vs 42. Bluefield State 3

Fort Valley State 30 vs. Savannah State 0

Tuskegee 27 vs. Edward Waters 13

NAIA

Florida Memorial 17 vs. St. Thomas (Fla.) 35

Langston 35 vs. Texas College 25

Arkansas Baptist 6 vs. Oklahoma Panhandle State 52

Trei Oliver uses fundraiser to take one more jab at North Carolina A&T football team

Trei Oliver1 2
As the North Carolina Central football team hits the road for Indianapolis and the Circle City Classic against Norfolk State, the program is currently conducting a unique fundraiser that head coach Trei Oliver spoke of in a video shared by the Eagle athletic department on X, formerly known as Twitter.

“I wanted to take time out before we have practice to thank our supporters that donated to our $66-dollar campaign,” Oliver said in a video posted Wednesday evening, alluding to NCCU’s 66-24 romp over bitter rival North Carolina A&T in the annual Aggie-Eagle Classic last Saturday.

Oliver went on to say that he would match the first $5,000 dollars donated, joking that “my wife still doesn’t know, so hopefully she doesn’t find out.”

Central begins MEAC play in the 40th Circle City Classic against Norfolk State on Saturday, Sept. 28, at 3 p.m. The Eagles have been picked to win the conference, while Norfolk State (2-3 in 2024) was selected fifth in the MEAC’s preseason polls.

HBCU football game rescheduled amid approaching Hurricane Helene

Hurricane Helene
Another HBCU football game has been impacted by Hurricane Helene.

Saturday’s game between Edward Waters and Tuskegee has been postponed “due to the impending inclement weather brought by Hurricane Helene,” Edward Waters officials announced on Wednesday.

“We here at Edward Waters University encourage everyone to prioritize safety during this time period,” the school said.

The game will now be played on Sunday at 4 p.m. EST at Edward Waters, a school located in Jacksonville, Florida.

Photo: Edward Waters Athletics

Helene was upgraded Thursday morning to a Category 2 storm and is expected to be a major hurricane—meaning a Category 3 or higher—when it makes landfall in Florida, the Associated Press reported. Hurricane and flash flood warnings extended far beyond the coast up into Georgia. The governors of Florida, Georgia, the Carolinas, and Virginia have all declared emergencies in their states.

The SWAC opener between Alabama A&M and Florida A&M was also postponed with Hurricane Helene approaching.

James Colzie has football-related message for new Florida A&M athletic director

James Colzie
Florida A&M this week announced the hire of new athletic director Angela Suggs.

Suggs, a FAMU alum, was previously the president and CEO of the Florida Sports Foundation and replaces Tiffani-Dawn Sykes, who was dismissed in August in a university staff purge by interim President Timothy Beard.

First-year head coach James Colzie was asked on Monday whether he expressed any football program-related desires for Suggs to handle despite her not officially starting until Oct. 7.

Photo: Angela Suggs/Florida A&M Athletics

Colize, who said he met with Suggs prior to her introductory press conference, didn’t share any specifics, though he did want to relay an important message.

“She’s a FAMU alum. She loves FAMU,” he said. “I would say to her love FAMU. I can’t necessarily share my wish list, but I would ask her if you love FAMU, continue to do so with the football program in mind.”

HBCU football games to watch: MEAC play begins and it’s getting late early for one SWAC team

Nccu 1
Highlighting Week 5 of the HBCU football season is a pair of CIAA matchups featuring teams eager to get in the win column for the first time in conference play.

Elsewhere, the first MEAC conference game of the season takes place in Indianapolis, while a SWAC West team fights for their conference championship hopes in a rivalry game.

Shaw vs. Virginia Union

When: September 28; Time: 1 p.m. ET

How to Watch: TheCIAASN

The Virginia Union Panthers are looking to return to the win column when they play in their home opener against the Shaw Bears.

Virginia Union dropped to 1-2 on the season after losing to Johnson C. Smith in its conference opener. Meanwhile, Shaw improved to 3-1 after handily beating Lincoln (PA). This marked the best start to a season for the Bears since 2009.

This is a must-win game for Virginia Union to keep their hopes of repeating as CIAA champions alive. History is on the Panthers’ side, as they have beaten the Bears in three of their last four meetings.

However, the last time these teams met in Richmond, Shaw won 27-7.

Fayetteville State vs. Virginia State

When: September 28; Time: 2 p.m. ET

How to Watch: TheCIAASN

Virginia State is also looking to bounce back after losing its conference opener, hosting the reigning CIAA championship runner-up Fayetteville State Broncos.

The Trojans are coming off a 15-14 loss to Winston-Salem State, which they lost on a game-winning field goal in the final seconds of the fourth quarter.

On the other hand, Fayetteville State returned from an idle week and opened CIAA play with a decisive 37-7 win over Elizabeth City State.

Although Fayetteville State has won its last two regular-season meetings against Virginia State, the Trojans won their previous matchup in Virginia to claim the 2017 CIAA championship.

Norfolk State vs. North Carolina Central

When: September 28; Time: 3 p.m. ET

How to Watch: ESPNU

The North Carolina Central Eagles begin their quest for the MEAC crown when they open their conference schedule against the Norfolk State Spartans.

North Carolina Central is coming off a thorough 66-24 beating of Aggie-Eagle Classic rival North Carolina A&T, setting a record for the most points scored in the series.

Norfolk State pulled off a dominant win of its own in its last outing against Virginia Military Institute, claiming a 32-10 victory.

The Spartans are looking for their first win over the Eagles since 2019 (they have lost the last three meetings).

Fort Valley State vs Savannah State

When: September 28; Time: 6 p.m. ET

How to Watch: ESPN+

After a big win against Tuskegee last weekend, Savannah State aims to keep itself in the win column when they welcome Fort Valley State to Theodore A. Wright Stadium.

Fort Valley State snapped a three-game losing streak against Savannah State last year, using a 21-point third quarter to knock off the Tigers.

Both teams enter this game with 1-1 conference records, making them two of seven teams in the SIAC with identical marks.

This is one of two SIAC matchups between teams with 1-1 conference records (the other being Benedict-Morehouse).

Prairie View A&M vs Grambling State

When: September 28; Time: 7 p.m. ET

How to Watch: ESPN+

Grambling State seeks to build off its big win against Jackson State when they face Prairie View A&M in the State Fair Classic.

Grambling State defeated Prairie View A&M in last year’s contest, claiming its first win over the Panthers since 2017 (five straight losses in between).

While this is Grambling’s first divisional matchup of the season, this game is crucial for Prairie View A&M, who already has two divisional losses on its record.

Alcorn State must fight against ‘immaturity’ to overcome slow start

Screenshot 2024 09 24 163020
Alcorn State, the presumptive preseason pick to win the SWAC West, limps into conference play after a 1-3 record through the first quarter of the regular season. The team is unsure of its direction and riddled with questions about its execution and maturity.

That is what can be gleaned from the 10-minute media session Braves coach Cedric Thomas spent on Monday diagnosing his team after four weeks.

According to Thomas, the list of items Alcorn State needed to address was lengthy. It starts with penalties that had hurt them in blowout nonconference losses to UAB, Vanderbilt, and McNeese State. The Braves have currently amassed 34 accepted infractions through the first 16 quarters of the season—good (or bad) for sixth among all teams in the SWAC.

In the 42-14 loss to McNeese last Saturday, Alcorn State compiled 10 penalties for 109 yards.

“We have to be more disciplined from that aspect,” said Thomas.

Almost as surprisingly, the Braves defense, a unit that had been solid when Thomas solely handled it under then-head coach Fred McNair, has not performed up to its reputation or standard.

Thomas lamented the lack of consistent tackling, which has resulted in Alcorn State allowing 36.3 points per game and 223.5 rushing yards per game. Its once strong defensive front has registered just two sacks.

“We’ve not played the brand of ball that we’ve played since I’ve been here,” he said. “We have to get back to the basic fundamentals of tackling and limit the big plays. We have to be better there. We have to give the offense more opportunities to score touchdowns.”

But that has been a problem area, too.

The Braves offense has scored seven TDs and averaged 13.8 points per game. Only Mississippi Valley State—Alcorn State’s next opponent—averages fewer at 10.8 points per contest.

Alcorn State football
Photo: Alcorn State Athletics

Beyond the statistical struggles on offense and defense, Thomas was not pleased with the team’s level of focus and intentionality up to this point, which has led to a widespread drop in execution.

When asked what was the common denominator in the regression, Thomas provided a candid one-word answer.

“Immaturity,” he said.  “Some of the mistakes are being made by freshmen. We have a redshirt freshman who fumbles the ball on the 1-yard line. We have a freshman punter who drops the ball twice in a row, even though we work on punting every day. It’s just maturity.

Some of those guys have to hurry up and step up … Whatever the deal is, I’m not doing a good enough job during the practice sessions for them to do it in the game.”

Thomas was adamant that the team would have to collectively work to perform better if the Braves aspired to compete for a division or conference championship.

“Regardless of win, lose or draw, we have to play well,” he said. “We owe our fans and everyone associated with this institution a better product. We will get it fixed.”

Florida A&M SWAC East opener postponed due to approaching hurricane

FAMU Football
Saturday was set to be Florida A&M’s SWAC East opener at Bragg Memorial Stadium against Alabama A&M, but with Hurricane Helene bearing down on the region, a change of plans was in order.

Tuesday morning, the university announced the game would be moved to Friday Nov. 29.

“Our top priority is the safety and well-being of our student-athletes, coaches, and staff,” FAMU acting athletic director Michael Smith said in a statement released by the university. “Given the uncertainty surrounding Hurricane Helene, we feel it is in everyone’s best interest to reschedule the game.”

Ticket and game information will be disclosed by the university at a later date, the school said. The Rattlers are 2-2 and have yet to play a conference game, as does Alabama A&M.

Ultimate HBCU Sports Division II Football Poll: Welcome to the rankings West Virginia State

WASTATEFB
The Johnson C. Smith Golden Bulls cemented their spot at the top of this week’s Division II poll after knocking off the defending CIAA champion Virginia Union Panthers.

Not far behind them is the Clark Atlanta Panthers, who overcame a 24-point deficit to pull off an upset win over the Bethune-Cookman Wildcats.

Here is this week’s Ultimate HBCU Sports Division II Football Poll.

Rank Team Previous Rank 2024 record
1 Johnson C. Smith 1 4-0
2 Clark Atlanta 3 3-0-1
3 Fayetteville State 5 2-1
4 Shaw 6 3-1
5 Winston-Salem State 7 3-1
6 West Virginia State NR 2-1
7 Virginia Union 2 1-2
8 Virginia State 4 1-2
9 Bowie State NR 1-2
10 Fort Valley State 10 1-2

Practice makes perfect for ballhawking Grambling State defense. How the Tigers do it

Patrick Marshall
The Grambling State football team is off to its best start since their 2017 SWAC championship year, winners of three straight heading into this weekend’s State Fair Classic in Dallas against Prairie View.

How are they doing it? Grambling defensive coordinator Jason Rollins shared a few key points during Monday’s SWAC Coaches’ Conference.

“You get what you emphasize. We talk about it, we chart every time the ball is touched, we have drills set up for takeaways,” Rollins said of the Tiger defense, which has 15 takeaways (nine interceptions, six fumble recoveries) in the first four games of 2024. “Coach Lee does a really good job of putting our takeaway circuits together. Coach Joseph has certain segments designed for taking care of the ball and taking the ball away.”

Grambling forced three turnovers against Jackson State in their 41-20 win last Saturday, two going for touchdowns.

Senior defensive back Caleb-Lee Collins returned an interception 22 yards for a touchdown with 47 seconds left in the first half to open up a 21-13 halftime lead. With 42 seconds to go in the third quarter, junior defensive back Patrick Marshall returned a fumble four yards for six to give the Tigers, now 3-1 on the season, some breathing room.

“We kept it simple and let our guys play fast and play with confidence,” Collins said of Week 4’s strategy. “We didn’t do anything different; we kept the game plan simple so they could line up and play as fast and physical as they could.”

Collins added the GSU defense doesn’t enter a game with any specific goal in mind – just to play to the best of their ability, take advantage of another team’s mistakes and create their own opportunities.

“It’s just muscle memory,” he explained. “If you catch ’em, strip ’em, scoop it up in practice, you’ll do it in a game.”