JROCK
Preeminent
I agree and disagree. First of all App State vs Michigan was a fluke of all flukes. The next week, Michigan would have beat them by 50 so while is a legendary story, it means nothing when comparing the two programs. It's their 11 vs our 11 but if 9 times outta 10, their 11 kick our azz, that 1 time ain't worth discussion.
BUT you are right that the numbers mean nothing. What matters is alumni/fan support and university investment. There are many large schools who don't belong in 1-A.. Georgia State is among them. I am not sure how University of South Alabama is doing but chances are, but they belong in 1-AA.. as do Troy, Georgia Southern, and UL-Monroe, etc.. I think App State is ready because the school and the administration says they are ready by their level of support. I bet App State fans would travel as well. They overflow their stadium every week and they win. That is how you know you are ready. I think they could win the Sunbelt in their first year. The same goes for University of Delaware. I have gone to games in their stadium. They are 1000% D-1AA material as is Villanova in football.
We need to take another look at our classification system and we need to really consider adhering to NCAA guidelines to what allows a school to be 1-A. If they don't meet the criteria, kick their azzez out! The same goes for 1-AA. If you can't afford 63 scholarships, yo azz need to be D2. PERIOD.
30,000 students GA. State doesn't belong in I-A because TP said so? Yea Right! :lol: :emlaugh: (those schools you listed are mid major schools up and down)