Was the teacher wrong in this case?


I understand your position but the concern is unmerited. The chair (or table) is not a weapon but a shield for yourself and the student(s) you are protecting. You are in a defensive posture. You announce to the assailant and for all witnesses to hear, "I am standing with this chair (table) to protect myself and this student from your attack. I will defend myself and the other students if you continue to attack." A law enforcement officer would tell the perp the same sort of thing. If the kid attacks and you subdue him without malice, you are covered.

Exactly and the students need to feel a sense of safety in the classroom. If any Tom, Dick or Harry can choose to pound on a student when he feels like it, what's the use of having class to begin with? Just let everybody fight it out.

De-escalation techniques and crisis plans should be taught at every school in every district. This would cut down on a lot of fights, injuries and lawsuits.
Schools should be some of the safest places for children, not some of the most danger-filled places.
 
I would've asked ONE of the students to leave and escorted him out the door. The teacher's in charge of safety in that classroom. Just standing there and doing nothing was laughable. One can't get a lawsuit for escorting a student out the door.

Plus fights usually start with words, then it escalates into something more. Teacher may need to learn de-escalation techniques on how to prevent fights before they start.
If the student being punched was a female or smaller kid, would you all have the patience to stand there and watch a dude pound on a female?
Wanna bet? As soon as you put your hands on that student to escorted him out, LAWSUIT!!!
 



Wanna bet? As soon as you put your hands on that student to escorted him out, LAWSUIT!!!

If the weaker student didn't want to leave, then that's on him/her, but usually the student leaves on his own volition. That's with any altercation. Separating the two should've been the first thing to do.
It's quite obvious that this man lacked de-escalation skills which is probably the district's fault.

The situation went on for quite some time in that video and no other adult showed up. Dude could've put a choke hold on the student and killed him right there in front of everybody if he wanted to and the teacher would've just stood there.

There should always be a crisis plan in place for something like this.
 
If the weaker student didn't want to leave, then that's on him/her, but usually the student leaves on his own volition. That's with any altercation. Separating the two should've been the first thing to do.
It's quite obvious that this man lacked de-escalation skills which is probably the district's fault.

The situation went on for quite some time in that video and no other adult showed up. Dude could've put a choke hold on the student and killed him right there in front of everybody if he wanted to and the teacher would've just stood there.

There should always be a crisis plan in place for something like this.

Dude, say what you wanna, but as soon as you touched that kid, LAWSUITS AND TERMINATION. Dont believe me? Look at this video about 10 students being arrested for starting a food fight and as soon as the police got there, they got arrested.



10 Students Arrested After Lovejoy High Food Fight (VIDEO)


Authorities said 10 students were arrested after a food fight broke out in the cafeteria at Lovejoy High School south of Atlanta.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported the food fight began Tuesday morning, and police officers who were on campus dealing with another matter tried to halt it.

Clayton County Police Officer Phong Nguyen said a few students didn't want to stop the food fight. He said one student jumped on the back of a police officer, and another student began cursing at another officer.

Nguyen said one of the officers deployed pepper foam during the melee.


Authorities said two of the students were charged with simple battery, obstruction, disorderly conduct and disruption of a public school.

Seven other students were also arrested and released to their parents.

http://www.star94.com/info2go/story.aspx?ID=1415795

Now one of the student's parent is talking about sueing the police, school, school district, principal, citizens of Lovejoy, fire stations, etc.... for pepper spraying his bad azz kid. And this dude can barely speak English.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wanna bet? As soon as you put your hands on that student to escorted him out, LAWSUIT!!!

They act like that shat don't happen on a weekly basis. Just more BS excuses for these little hudlems and their sue happy parents. Don't even think the schools administration will help the teacher when Mr. and Mrs. My baby ain't dome nothing" come their raising hell about a teacher putting their hands on a student a physically doing what it takes to break these thugs up from fighting.

I hope that fired teacher sue this district to no ends.
I'm glad the majority of my family got out of this profession. Only 2 teacher left and they can't wait to give it up.
 
Dude, say what you wanna, but as soon as you touched that kid, LAWSUITS AND TERMINATION. Dont believe me? Look at this video about 10 students being arrested for starting a food fight and as soon as the police got there, they got arrested.





Now one of the student's parent is talking about sueing the police, school, school district, principal, citizens of Lovejoy, fire stations, etc.... And this dude can barely speak English.

Game, set, and match.
Anymore questions?
 
Game, set, and match.
Anymore questions?
J83, Jayrob really dont fully understand.

Dude, say what you wanna, but as soon as you touched that kid, LAWSUITS AND TERMINATION. Dont believe me? Look at this video about 10 students being arrested for starting a food fight and as soon as the police got there, they got arrested.

Now one of the student's parent is talking about sueing the police, school, school district, principal, citizens of Lovejoy, fire stations, etc.... for pepper spraying his bad azz kid. And this dude can barely speak English.

Here is the other story to the above story:

Man May Sue After Son Arrested In Food Fight

CLAYTON COUNTY, Ga. -- The father of one of the students arrested in a massive food fight at a local high school is threatening to sue.

Jessee Rivera believes officers pepper-sprayed his son, 18-year-old Jefferson Rivera, after he was handcuffed.

"I'm gonna sue the city, and the school and the police," Rivera told Channel 2's Tom Jones. "I will sue them 'cause my child don't have no right to be handcuffed, and somebody gonna pepper-spray like he’s a criminal."

Clayton County police strongly denied that any students were pepper-sprayed after they were handcuffed.

The food fight took place on the Lovejoy High School campus just after 11 a.m. on Tuesday. Officers arrested nine students, including five juveniles, in connection with the incident.

Students Jefferson Rivera, Eric Fuentes, Markail Horton and Juan Lopez made their first court appearance in front of Clayton Clayton County Magistrate Judge Bobby Simmons on Wednesday.

Simmons told Rivera he faces obstruction, disruption of the operation of a public school and simple battery on a police officer. The judge then read the accusation against Rivera.

"It says when a food fight in the commons (began), (the) defendant was using abusive language, throwing food in the commons (area). When an officer tried to take him into custody, he refused and started to fight with Officer James and myself," Simmons read. Police also said Rivera cursed at them.

http://www.wsbtv.com/news/27859592/detail.html
And like I said, this parent can barely speak English, but he do know the words "SUE!"
 
Dude, say what you wanna, but as soon as you touched that kid, LAWSUITS AND TERMINATION. Dont believe me? Look at this video about 10 students being arrested for starting a food fight and as soon as the police got there, they got arrested.





Now one of the student's parent is talking about sueing the police, school, school district, principal, citizens of Lovejoy, fire stations, etc.... for pepper spraying his bad azz kid. And this dude can barely speak English.

That situation is totally different from the one I'm talking about. You're comparing apples and oranges, which is a student being voluntarily escorted out of the classroom for his own safety versus students attacking police officers. Those are two totally different situations.

Those students who were attacking officers brought that on themselves by their actions.
 
That situation is totally different from the one I'm talking about. You're comparing apples and oranges, which is a student being voluntarily escorted out of the classroom for his own safety versus students attacking police officers. Those are two totally different situations.

Those students who were attacking officers brought that on themselves by their actions.

Dude, this is the same scenario. SUEING for attempting to stop an altercation. Whether it's a fight or food fight. Those kids at Lovejoy was arrested for throwing food in the cafe, not attacking an officer. They were pepper sprayed for "resisting arrest". Please re-read the article and let it digest on your mind.

7 to 10 kids got arrested, only one jumped on the back of an officer.
 
Dude, this is the same scenario. SUEING for attempting to stop an altercation. Whether it's a fight or food fight. Those kids at Lovejoy was arrested for throwing food in the cafe, not attacking an officer. They were pepper sprayed for "resisting arrest". Please re-read the article and let it digest on your mind.

7 to 10 kids got arrested, only one jumped on the back of an officer.

How is the same situation when one student is leaving of his own volition, while the students you mentioned are acting plumb crazy by attacking police officers? Again, two different situations requiring two different methods of handling.

One has to do with poor classroom management by the teacher, the other has to do with poor schoolwide management.

Students jumping on the back of a police officer are lucky they weren't hit with billyclubs, tazered or even shot.
As far as teachers putting their hands on students, it seems to be more of a case where the police officers had to put their hands on students, not the teachers.
Throwing any object can be seen as an assault, so these parents may have no leg to stand on in this case if their child was found guilty of throwing objects at other students and violating school and district policy. In fact, the district could in turn sue the parents if they so chose to do.
 
Last edited:
Jayrob, did you read the article?

Yes, I did. The fact of the matter is that any parent can sue the district for anything they want to sue them for. People are so afraid to do the right thing for fear of a lawsuit. If a teacher's following proper district protocol with a mixture of commonsense, they usually have no problem.
Now getting back to the first video, what if that was a female the student was punching. Would anyone, as a decent man/woman just stand there and let ole dude pound blood from the female for fear of a lawsuit? Just curious.

There's a reason why they teach classroom management, de-escalation techniques and crisis planning in districts. It's called being proactive.
 



Then if you read it, then you would know the students was arrested for the food fight. One student jumped on the officer's back to prevent his friend from being arrested over the food fight. Then the officer pepper sprayed the students. Short and sweet.

Now, you trying to escort the child out the room. Are you talking about the child getting beat or the one doing the beating?
 
Yeah, would you arrest the student who got punched in the face by the other student in the first video? Two completely different scenarios.

In that one you would have to get some more background information. Watch it and listen to what the boy doing the punching is saying-"You want to call me a (bleeping) f*ggot." From what I understand and have been told the victim starts up stuff and doesn't back it up. Isn't it odd that he just stood there and took those punches and didn't leave until the other kid told him to get out? In that one it seems the teacher is letting "justice" be done.

I would have gotten the one being punched out of the classroom.

Now that second with a kid stripping to fight and camera phones all setup? The teacher was WRONG. He has to be gone after that one. I can't defend that.

De-escalation techniques and crisis plans should be taught at every school in every district. This would cut down on a lot of fights, injuries and lawsuits.
Schools should be some of the safest places for children, not some of the most danger-filled places.

It is taught at many schools. Even ways to restrain a kid is taught. However those courses cost MONEY and in many cases take personal time on the staff to learn that stuff. Even if you learn all that stuff-you can still be fired or put on leave.

See many school districts like mine are HATED by the community. You have parents that will SEND thier kids to school just to get teachers/staff fired. A former principal was attacked by a kid TWICE and the community sided with the kid. Oh and don't be a white empolyee facing a black kid-you will lose. I know one who quit because he feared he was going to kill the next kid that put hands on him because he was white. Never mind he was a Marine built like The Rock.

There's a reason why they teach classroom management, de-escalation techniques and crisis planning in districts. It's called being proactive.

That stuff doesn't work on Pookie and Ray Ray. All that stuff doesn't cover OUR kids. Remember most of these training are done in white school districts where Degrassi, Glee and High School Musical are. Where PARENTS are active in thier kids education and kids are WILLING to listen and want to be more than a jailbird or dropout. Kids aren't that bold like they are in the second video.
 
skyvolt2000 [QUOTE said:
In that one you would have to get some more background information. Watch it and listen to what the boy doing the punching is saying-"You want to call me a (bleeping) f*ggot." From what I understand and have been told the victim starts up stuff and doesn't back it up. Isn't it odd that he just stood there and took those punches and didn't leave until the other kid told him to get out? In that one it seems the teacher is letting "justice" be done.

Who hasn't been called a name? Still, this is when the teacher could've and should've intervened. If the teachers don't show any kind of control in the classroom, then any student can attack another if he/she was called a name. Usually, as the teacher goes, so go the classroom.

I would have gotten the one being punched out of the classroom.

That's the one I was talking about. Remove him and the situation would more than likely have died down.

It is taught at many schools. Even ways to restrain a kid is taught. However those courses cost MONEY and in many cases take personal time on the staff to learn that stuff. Even if you learn all that stuff-you can still be fired or put on leave.

Lawsuits cost money too. If schools don't put preventive measures in place on the front end, this is what they'll get on the back end. A school usually gets back from the students what it puts in. Students usually know what classes they can act a fool in and what classes they can't.

See many school districts like mine are HATED by the community. You have parents that will SEND thier kids to school just to get teachers/staff fired. A former principal was attacked by a kid TWICE and the community sided with the kid.

Then that student should be suspended or expelled if there's evidence to show that he/she wasn't provoked by the teacher. Teachers have known to provoke students you know.

Oh and don't be a white empolyee facing a black kid-you will lose. I know one who quit because he feared he was going to kill the next kid that put hands on him because he was white. Never mind he was a Marine built like The Rock.

This is where the principal needs to support and protect his staff. If there are students who are bent on attacking staff, they need to be removed from the building. The teacher also has a right to press charges as well.

That stuff doesn't work on Pookie and Ray Ray. All that stuff doesn't cover OUR kids. Remember most of these training are done in white school districts where Degrassi, Glee and High School Musical are. Where PARENTS are active in thier kids education and kids are WILLING to listen and want to be more than a jailbird or dropout. Kids aren't that bold like they are in the second video.

So our kids are outlaws and nothing can reel them in because they're unruly monsters? Come on dude, I totally disagree with that. Of course you have that small 2-3 percent of students that don't give a damn about anything. They only care about doing what they wanna do when they wanna do as long as they wanna do it. These are the ones that need more intensive services in the school and perhaps in an alternative setting. They shouldn't be allowed to threaten and intimidate teachers without repercussions and consequences from the administrators.

Most of the de-escalation trainings are done in diverse populations and most of the time, if they're applied correctly, especially the verbal de-escalation techniques, they've been shown to work. I'm speaking from firshand experience.
What happens is that some adults get on the level of Ray-Ray, which is what Ray-Ray wants them to do, and they end up making the situation worse and putting themselves in a worse situation.

If Ray-Ray and his thugs want to attack adults, the principal should have the courage and balls to get them out of the school and into an alternative setting, but they need the evidence to show that they've put things in place to prevent physical assaults.
Where a lot of schools/districts get in trouble is when they don't have evidence to show that they've put in place preventive measures via trainings and crisis planning to help prevent violent incidents. If push comes to shove, this would be their evidence if the matter ever went to court and this would be the evidence that they could show the parents, where the teacher tried everything possible to work with their child, but the child wouldn't cooperate. With such evidence, the parent hasn't a leg to stand on with the school board or the court system, nevertheless the district MUST be held accountable to put those things in place regardless of the population they're working with. Districts have standards they must abide by just like students do.

Again, the teachers also have the right to file charges and protect themselves as well. No staff member is supposed to just sit there and let a student physically attack him/her.
 
Then if you read it, then you would know the students was arrested for the food fight. One student jumped on the officer's back to prevent his friend from being arrested over the food fight. Then the officer pepper sprayed the students. Short and sweet.

Now, you trying to escort the child out the room. Are you talking about the child getting beat or the one doing the beating?

The one getting punched. From the looks of the video, that wouldn't have been a problem at all. Now if the student wanted to stay in that situation and get pounded, then that's on him.
 
Back
Top