South Carolina State is Celebration Bowl bound. Which SWAC contender could give them a game?

Screenshot 2026 11 18 002322

South Carolina State has established itself as the team to beat in HBCU football. The Bulldogs have won three consecutive MEAC championships and are preparing for another trip to the Celebration Bowl.

But if the SWAC sends Alabama A&M, Jackson State, Southern or Prairie View A&M to Atlanta, which team would give Chennis Berry’s squad its toughest challenge?

The case for Alabama A&M

Alabama A&M might have the best combination of offensive and defensive personnel to challenge South Carolina State.

Offensively, the Bulldogs have the ability to attack through the air and on the ground. Running backs Kolton Nero and Byron Perrillliat provide a two-headed rushing attack, while the passing game behind quarterback Quad Brown IV and his 25 touchdowns gives Alabama A&M another way to move the football.

But the Bulldogs will be without star wide receiver Jarel Williams, who is out for the regular season after undergoing shoulder surgery. That big-time playmaker not being on the field against one of the top teams in the FCS in a championship game situation will be a disadvantage.

Alabama A&M also has a defense capable of making life difficult for Keely Watson. Its secondary has shown an ability to create turnovers with 10 interceptions, and its defensive front is tied for the SWAC lead with 26 sacks this season.

The concern is the South Carolina State defensive line. If the Bulldogs defensive front can keep up its knack for creating pressure (35 sacks this season), Alabama A&M will have to look for other options to move the ball.

Jackson State has a solid defense but …

Jackson State has the defensive personnel to make this a particularly interesting matchup.

The Tigers have been effective against opposing rushing attacks, only allowing a SWAC-best 115 yards per game, and that ability would be critical against a South Carolina State rushing attack that gains 204 yards on the ground each outing. The Bulldogs want to establish their running game, create manageable passing situations, and keep Watson comfortable.

Jackson State’s defensive front could disrupt that plan.

Offensively, the Tigers have an opportunity to attack South Carolina State vertically. Quarterback Jared Lockhart — despite his inconsistent play down the stretch — has thrown 20 TDs (third in the SWAC) and is only second in passer efficiency rating behind all-world Alcorn State quarterback Jaylon Tolbert. If he can take care of the ball in this hypothetical matchup. The Tigers have the talent on offense to stay with the Bulldogs.

Nate Blount and Li’Darius Pryor, when healthy and available, also give Jackson State options in the running game.

The problem is offensive consistency. Against Alabama State, Jackson State managed just 68 rushing yards and converted only three of 12 third downs. It also committed three costly turnovers. T.C. Taylor has recently talked about the Tigers getting off to better starts.

South Carolina State’s defense would welcome those mistakes.

Trey Holly could be the difference maker

Southern has perhaps the most obvious offensive game plan against South Carolina State if they were to meet: give Trey Holly the football and make the Bulldogs defend the run for four quarters.

Holly has rushed for 1,393 yards and 14 touchdowns. His production gives Southern a legitimate weapon capable of controlling possession, creating explosive runs and keeping the opposing offense on the sideline.

A productive rushing attack would also help protect Southern’s defense by limiting SC State’s offensive opportunities.

The Jaguars could use play-action passing to capitalize on South Carolina State’s commitment to stopping Holly.

Defensively, however, Southern has a much bigger challenge. The Jaguars have allowed 29.6 points per game, and their inability to consistently stop opposing offenses could become a problem against a team as efficient as South Carolina State, even though star defensive lineman Ckelby Givens is a terror up front.

Southern would need to win the turnover battle and generate pressure without repeatedly exposing its secondary. Oh, and give Holly the ball.

Prairie View A&M: Defense could give the Panthers a chance

How about a rematch?

The Panthers bullied South Carolina State for three quarters in last year’s Celebration Bowl before the Bulldogs pulled off an epic overtime comeback.

Their 13-10 victory over Arkansas-Pine Bluff demonstrated that they can win when the offense is not producing explosive numbers. More importantly, their 31-10 victory over Alabama A&M — likely SWAC title game opponent — showed the defense’s ability to overwhelm an elite group.

Offensively, Prairie View would need consistent play from quarterback Tevin Carter, who has had his ups and downs this season at the helm, leading an offense that has scored 33 TDs as a unit, good for eighth in the SWAC. As coach Tremaine Jackson says, the offense goes as he goes.

Against a defense that can generate sacks and tackles for loss, Prairie View needs more explosive plays than it has consistently produced.